FLEET management provider CBVC Vehicle Management is urging financial advisors and accountants to encourage businesses to ignore headline lease rental rates and to instead focus on whole life costs for company car acquisition for fleet cost savings.
According to CBVC, understanding whole life costs is critical, especially as fleets start to accommodate electric vehicles. Focusing simply on monthly lease rates will not only skew fleet policy, but it could lead to greater costs for the business and the driver.
Mike Manners, managing director of CBVC Vehicle Management said: “As the country emerges from the pandemic, many of the historic assumptions about business have been challenged, from working in offices to virtual meetings. The shape of the company car fleet is another area that faces fundamental change.
“As zero-emission cars typically have higher list prices than traditional internal combustion-engine (ICE) vehicles, savings on fuel, maintenance and tax can easily offset any initial difference and make electric vehicles much cheaper. This makes whole life cost comparisons a critical part of any fuel transition plan, to ensure that the right technology options are deployed in the most suitable areas.”
Example:
Tesla model 3 has a £40,935 list price for a Standard Plus model, when an equivalent petrol BMW 3 Series 320i M Sport is £38,415 or a diesel 318d SE Pro is £34,665.
The headline lease rates reveal the Tesla costs £555 per month over three years/60,000 miles while the petrol BMW costs £483 over the same profile.
But implementing a whole life cost approach dispels the assumption that the EV is more expensive than either of the ICE models.
CBVC calculations show the true monthly cost of the Tesla. When the rental, VAT recovery, maintenance costs, Corporation Tax deductions, insurance, and Class 1A National Insurance Contributions are considered, the actual cost is £653 per month, compared with the petrol BMW at £757 per month, while the diesel is £699.
Overall, the Tesla will cost a company £23,517 over a three-year cycle compared with £27,256 for the petrol BMW and £25,155 for the BMW diesel.
During a three-year operating cycle, the diesel BMW driver would pay £12,348 in benefit-in-kind tax and the petrol BMW driver would incur a company car tax bill of £15,516. In contrast, the Tesla driver would pay £864, saving £11,484 and £14,652 respectively compared with the BMWs.
For businesses not ready to switch to a fully electric operating fleet, a plug-in hybrid vehicle (PHEV) offers a cost-effective way to move away from a dependency on diesel and petrol company cars.
Accountants should be aware that although more expensive than the petrol or diesel alternative, the PHEV has a lower whole life cost, equivalent to £20,831 over a three-year cycle.
And drivers will only spend £5,580 on tax over three years – less than half the amount incurred by drivers of a petrol or diesel vehicle. This knowledge will help the client save thousands of pounds over a three-year cycle.
It’s a similar story if the operating cycle is changed, for example to four years/80,000 miles.1
Manners added: “When advising clients, accountants should be aware that an analysis of whole life costs demonstrates a strong financial argument for businesses to begin the switch to zero-emission motoring, and with the right approach, a business can unlock significant savings while also cutting emissions at the same time and reducing their carbon footprint. One note of caution, when modelling plug-in hybrids, as forecast fuel economy is derived in test conditions, numbers are substantially higher than those achieved in actual running conditions.”
19May
Northgate are in it for the long haul
WHEN it comes to long term rental, Northgate offers a comprehensive range of support packages for SMEs, with a wide range of fleet solutions to meet the diverse needs of
18May
ChargedEV – helping SMEs on their electrification journey
CHARGEDEV specialises in the supply and installation of Electric Vehicle charging equipment across the UK and having installed over 23,000 domestic and workplace EV chargers to date, it has become
17May
R2C – digitising the fleet management process
R2C Lite has been created to eliminate labour-intensive administration processes, aid compliance and increase business productivity for SME fleets running HGVs, vans, trucks, trailers and more, many of which will
17May
Northgate’s mobility solutions keeping you on the road
NORTHGATE Vehicle Hire's additional mobility solutions options and support packages can be built into its existing rental contracts, cutting down the need for multiple supplier agreements to be signed and
09May
BMW – looking after fleets large and small
WHETHER you are a sole trader looking for a car that works for your business or you manage a fleet of fewer than 50 company cars, the BMW Business Partnership
04May
BMW i4 – makes a lot of sense for the company car driver
THE new BMW i4 is the German premium brand's first ever all-electric Gran Coupé and it's a very interesting proposition for company car drivers with a 2% BIK rate for
03May
Innovation drives Wilson Auctions’ success
AS one of the first in the industry to introduce MVR (Motor Vehicle Repair Workshops) on its various auction sites nationwide, Wilson Auctions was highly commended in this year's Business
28Apr
Tax efficiency – BMW’s X1 PHEV, a Business Motoring winner
BMW's X1 xDrive 25e is a Business Motoring winner, picking up the Best Small SUV gong at this year's awards. It features a 1.5-litre three-cylinder petrol engine and electric motor
27Apr
BMW X5e – makes real sense to drivers and fleet managers
THE BMW X5 xDrive 45e offers user-choosers a large SUV which delivers low running costs and associated tax bills. Thanks to CO2 emissions of 27-31g/km, the X5 falls into the
27Apr
Van Monster Remarketing – tops for Business Motoring Awards
EXCEPTIONAL levels of customer service are at the heart of the Van Monster Remarketing proposition. The personal nature of the service provided by its Remarketing account managers has enabled to grow
25Apr
BMW iX electrifies the Business Motoring Award judges
THE BMW iX will add electric performance to any forward-thinking fleet manager, as well as a spacious, lounge-like interior to keep drivers focussed on the road ahead, with a range
22Apr
BMW iX3 brings electricity into the mainstream
Following the i3 and i8, the BMW iX3 is the brand's first electric SUV and the winner of this Year's Business Motoring Awards Best Medium SUV category. And the electric
19Apr
Executive express – BMW530e offers savings for company car drivers
THE BMW 5 Series Saloon is the epitome of a sporty business saloon and The 530e plug-in hybrid models combine performance and frugality to create an optimised executive car. With
13Apr
KeyFleet Partner Programme – Best Company Car Programme winner
WITH electric vehicles on the rise and with many government initiatives and support of the EV revolution, KeyFleet has become an ambassador for EVs.All employees are trained in Whole Life
13Apr
Keeping up with the times – Europcar, Business Motoring Award winner
MULTI-MODEL mobility is becoming increasingly important for SMEs, particularly in the short-term rental arena and the EuropcarOne mobility platform provides seamless access to a full range of solutions, from daily
12Apr
SOGO – Business Motoring Best Mobility Provider Winner
SHORT-TERM leasing is essential to the mass adoption of electric vehicles before 2030 when sales of all new cars and vans powered wholly by petrol and diesel will be banned.
11Apr
Flexibility is key – Europcar, Best Long Term Rental
FROM COVID-19 and semi-conductor shortages impacting on vehicle supply to rising inflation and uncertain trading conditions, the past 12 months have not been easy for any business. But they have
08Apr
Size doesn’t matter to Best Leasing Company winner JCT600 VLS
GIVING customers access to the same industry-leading solutions, service and technology, no matter what their size, is at the heart of the business at JCT600 Vehicle Leasing Solutions (VLS), winner
07Apr
Smart charger – Ohme a Business Motoring Award winner
ELECTRIC Vehicles are what everyone is talking about, as is the infrastructure required to make them a viable proposition. Helping to build this infrastructure is Ohme, a smart charging hardware
Chris Wright has been covering the automotive industry nationally and internationally for 30 years. Following spells with consumer titles he became News Editor of Automotive Management (AM), Editor of Automotive International, International Editor for Detroit-based Automotive News, and Editor of Dealer Update. He has also co-authored several FT Management Reports and contributes regularly to Justauto.com
Leave A Comment